Saudis vowed to cease executing minors; some demise sentences stay, rights teams say By Reuters

Saudis vowed to cease executing minors; some demise sentences stay, rights teams say By Reuters

© Reuters. Ali al-Nimr is seen on this undated handout picture


By Raya Jalabi

DUBAI (Reuters) – 5 individuals who dedicated crimes in Saudi Arabia as minors have but to have their demise sentences revoked, based on two rights teams, 9 months after the dominion’s Human Rights Fee (HRC) introduced an finish to capital punishment for juvenile offenders.

The state-backed HRC in April cited a March royal decree by King Salman stipulating that people sentenced to demise for crimes dedicated whereas minors will now not face execution and would as a substitute serve jail phrases of as much as 10 years in juvenile detention facilities.

The assertion didn’t specify a timeline, however in October, in response to a report by Human Rights Watch (HRW), it stated the decree had come into drive instantly upon announcement.

    The decree was by no means carried on state media nor printed within the official gazette as could be regular apply.

In December, state information company SPA printed an inventory of distinguished “occasions” of 2020 that includes a number of royal decrees, however the demise penalty order was not included.

Organisations together with anti-death penalty group Reprieve, HRW and the European-Saudi Group for Human Rights (ESOHR) in addition to a gaggle of U.S. lawmakers have raised considerations that loopholes in Saudi legislation may nonetheless enable judges to impose the demise sentence on juvenile offenders.

One of many 5 has appealed and eight face costs that might end in execution, stated the teams, who observe the instances intently.

Reuters established the standing of three of the 5 people by HRC statements however couldn’t independently confirm the opposite two.

The federal government’s Middle for Worldwide Communications (CIC) dismissed the considerations, telling Reuters that the royal decree could be utilized retroactively to all instances the place a person was sentenced to demise for offenses dedicated beneath the age of 18.

“The Royal Order issued in March 2020 was put in force instantly upon its issuance and was circulated to the related authorities for immediate implementation,” the CIC stated in an emailed assertion.

The HRC declined to remark.


Saudi Arabia, whose human rights document got here beneath international scrutiny after the 2018 homicide of journalist Jamal Khashoggi by Saudi brokers, is without doubt one of the world’s high executioners after Iran and China, rights teams say.

Its de facto chief Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, identified internationally as MbS, loved sturdy assist from U.S. President Donald Trump.

However President-elect Joe Biden, who takes over within the White Home later this week, has described the dominion as a “pariah” for its rights document and stated he would take a harder line.

Six U.S. senators wrote to the Saudi embassy in the US in October urging the dominion to assessment all ongoing demise penalty instances to establish people convicted for crimes dedicated once they have been youngsters, based on a replica of the letter seen by Reuters.

One of many signatories, Democratic Rep. Tom Malinowski, advised Reuters in December that if the dominion have been to observe by on the execution of juvenile offenders, “it might make it even more durable for Saudi Arabia to return to the type of relationships that it desires with the US.”

    He added that Biden could be trying on the kingdom’s human rights insurance policies “very otherwise to Trump”.

    Biden officers declined to remark for this text, however referred Reuters to an earlier assertion saying the brand new administration would reassess U.S. ties with Saudi Arabia.


Ali al-Nimr and Dawood al-Marhoun have been 17 once they have been detained in 2012 on costs associated to taking part in widespread protests within the Shi’ite-majority Jap Province. Abdullah al-Zaher was 15 when he was arrested.

The three, who’re among the many 5 juvenile offenders whose demise penalties have but to be revoked, have been sentenced to demise by the Specialised Prison Court docket and confronted beheading, though the general public prosecutor ordered a assessment of their sentences in August.

The CIC stated the royal decree could be utilized to their instances.

Their legal professionals couldn’t instantly be reached for remark.

In 2018, after assuming his submit in a palace coup that ousted the earlier crown prince, MbS pledged to minimise the usage of the demise penalty as a part of sweeping social reforms.

    However in 2019, a document variety of about 185 individuals have been executed, based on the rights teams.

Reuters couldn’t independently verify the figures. The CIC didn’t remark when requested whether or not this determine was correct.


In an article printed final April, state-linked newspaper Okaz confirmed the existence of the royal decree, however stated that the abolishment solely utilized to a lesser class of offence beneath Islamic legislation often called “ta’zeer”.

These crimes will not be clearly outlined within the Koran or accompanying Hadiths and so punishments are left to judges’ discretion, and may quantity to demise.

Saudi Arabia has no civil penal code that units out sentencing guidelines, and no system of judicial precedent that will make the result of instances extra predictable based mostly on previous apply.

    Judges may nonetheless sentence baby offenders to demise beneath the opposite two classes, based on Saudi Arabia’s interpretation of sharia: “houdoud”, or severe crimes which carry a prescribed punishment, together with terrorism, and “qisas”, or retribution, normally for homicide, two legal professionals and the rights teams stated.

Requested why the royal decree was by no means printed and whether or not it solely applies to the “ta’zeer” class of offense, the CIC declined to remark.

Some defendants in protest instances have been prosecuted on terror costs.

    In a case watched intently by the rights teams, 18-year-old Mohammad al-Faraj was dealing with the demise penalty although he was 15 on the time of his arrest in 2017 for costs together with taking part in protests and attending associated funerals, one when he was aged 9.

Forward of his subsequent listening to scheduled for Jan. 18, a supply near one of many defendants in Faraj’s case stated the demand for a “houdoud” demise sentence had lately been withdrawn and prosecutors have been as a substitute searching for the harshest punishment beneath “ta’zeer”.

The CIC stated the royal decree would apply retroactively to Faraj’s case. ESOHR expressed concern that with out a printed decree, the chance of capital punishment can’t be dominated out.

ESOHR stated Faraj was solely granted a state-appointed lawyer in October, was not delivered to court docket and was tortured in detention, allegations the CIC denied.

    Because the begin of the pandemic, Faraj has been allowed one weekly 15-minute name to his dad and mom, with in-person visits cancelled, a supply near the household stated.

Reuters was unable to independently verify the specifics of his case.